Why do companies ask about industry experience when choosing a partner?
The question comes up in almost every selection meeting, usually early: "Have you worked with companies like ours before?" It is a fair question. In an interview study by BearingPoint among managers of Finnish industrial companies, the technical expertise and the industry and business knowledge of the key people in the project are among the most important criteria when choosing an implementation partner, alongside cost (BearingPoint, ERP Study 2025, June 2025). Among German mid-sized companies, the weighting is already shifting. In the survey "ERP challenges 2025/26" by the ERP vendor Planat of 150 manufacturing companies, 82 per cent name the provider's ERP experience as a criterion for modernisation, 37 per cent the software's specialisation in an industry and only 28 per cent the provider's industry experience (Planat, November 2025).
More interesting than the question is what is meant by industry knowledge. Because the answer to that has shifted in recent years.
What did industry knowledge mean in the past?
For a long time, industry knowledge in ERP consulting meant above all knowing the industry solution. Anyone implementing for a furniture manufacturer knew the furniture solution, its screens, its settings and its limits. That was valuable because the standard could not do many things and the industry solution closed the gap. Consultant and software were chosen together, and a good part of the consultant's experience consisted of knowing the software very well. Anyone who changed the software therefore often changed the consultant too, and with them a large part of the knowledge about their own company.
This picture only partly holds today. The Business Central standard covers far more than it did ten years ago, and with AI features in the standard the boundary is shifting further. Why industry solutions do not disappear because of this, but take on a different role, is described in the article Does an ERP still need industry solutions?
What does the industry standard reflect, and what does it not?
An industry standard describes how most companies in an industry work. That is a good starting point and a poor end point. Because no company wins customers by working the way everyone else does. The competitive advantage almost always lies in a deviation: a particular way of building variants, a service model the competition does not have, a delivery promise that only holds with a certain planning logic.
A consultant who only knows the industry standard implements that standard. The project is then quick and tidy, and in the end the company works a little more like its competitors. A consultant who understands the business first asks where the company is different, and why.
The industry standard is a good starting point and a poor end point.
Which industry knowledge counts today?
Industry knowledge remains important, but it is shifting from the software to the business. Anyone who has supported many companies in an industry quickly recognises which deviation carries a real advantage and which is just habit. That is the real contribution: not rebuilding every special case, but protecting the few that define the business and solving the rest in the standard.
Added to this is a second part that has little to do with the industry and yet often decides the outcome: experience with projects of this size and complexity. Several legal entities, several countries, a data foundation that has grown over time. The BearingPoint study names the introduction of new operating models as well as data migration and data quality as the most difficult parts of an ERP programme. Industry knowledge alone solves none of these.
How can you test this in the first meeting?
With a simple question: "What is different about our business compared with the others in our industry?" A consultant who mainly knows the software answers with functions. A consultant who understands the business asks questions back, about customers, margins, delivery promises and who decides on processes in the company. The second answer is the less comfortable one, and it is the more useful one.
Equally revealing is who actually works on the project. Industry knowledge only helps if it sits with the people who prepare the decisions, not just in the presentation. What this means for how a consulting team is set up is described under What is senior-led ERP consulting?
How we support projects with industry knowledge
We have been supporting ERP projects for more than 25 years, senior-led, nationally and with rollouts in up to 25 countries. Business Central is our home. We use our industry knowledge where it makes the difference: in deciding which special features define your business and therefore have to be mapped properly, and which are better handled in the standard.
Are you facing a selection or a new project and want to know where your business deviates from the industry standard? Then we are happy to talk about it. The first conversation is about your situation, without a presentation and without a proposal.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a consultant who already knows my industry?
It helps, but it is not the most important criterion. What matters more is whether the consultant understands where your business deviates from what is usual in the industry, and has experience with projects of your size and complexity.
Is an industry solution a sign of good industry knowledge?
Not necessarily. An industry solution shows that someone knows the software for an industry. Whether they understand your business only shows in the questions they ask.
How much deviation from the standard makes sense?
As little as possible, as much as necessary. Deviations are worthwhile where they carry a competitive advantage. Everything else should run in the standard, because every deviation has to be maintained with every update.
Stay on top of things without tracking everything yourself.
Once a month, Frank Maier puts into context what is moving in the ERP world. Plus the invitation to the next live webinar.
About one email a month. Unsubscribe at any time with one click. Privacy policy


